Remove Tag?

Do you want to untag yourself from this post?

The Command Ship

Proposed Changes to Fleet Command and Other Mundane Matters (FCOMM)

Posted by Admiral Joe P (Librarian / TECH Chairman) in Proposed Changes to Fleet Command and Other Mundane Matters (FCOMM)

Posted by Fleet Captain Adam W. (Former Ruler of the Club) in Proposed Changes to Fleet Command and Other Mundane Matters (FCOMM)

Posted by David Wonderly in Proposed Changes to Fleet Command and Other Mundane Matters (FCOMM)
Doing some back reading and it looked to me that there could be some updates made to FCOMM to keep up with the current state of STF.

So, here we go. I formally propose we make the following changes to FCOMM as rev.7


Document: Fleet Command and Other Mundane Matters (FCOMM)
Section: Fleet Structure and Command
Subsection: Restrictions

Currently reads:

The Fleet Commander must be a current or former CO of the fleet in question, or a current or former XO in the fleet in question with CO experience. The Assistant Fleet Commander must be a current or former CO or XO of the fleet in question. Equivalent positions in an Alternate RPG Area may count equivalently. Acting CO or XO does not count.No individual may be the Fleet Commander or Assistant Fleet Commander of more than one Fleet at a time, nor may any individual be Fleet Commander of one Fleet and Assistant Fleet Commander of another Fleet at the same time. The President may not be the Fleet Commander or Assistant Fleet Commander of any Fleet. Acting holder of a position does not count towards these restrictions.

Proposed Changes:

The Fleet Commander must be a current or former CO, or a current or former XO. The Assistant Fleet Commander must be a current or former CO or XO. Equivalent positions in an Alternate RPG Area may count equivalently. Acting CO or XO does not count.No individual may be the Fleet Commander or Assistant Fleet Commander of more than one Fleet at a time, nor may any individual be Fleet Commander of one Fleet and Assistant Fleet Commander of another Fleet at the same time. The President may not be the Fleet Commander or Assistant Fleet Commander of any Fleet. Acting holder of a position does not count towards these restrictions.


This removes the mentions of being current in the fleet, while leaving the requirement of CO or XO somewhere in the club intact. There are no limitations of rank within the FComm or aFComm. Also, there is no mention in the FCOMM that the President must approve or appoint the aFComm.

Discuss?

Dave

I would be good with this if the last six words in the first sentence are removed. You’re not qualified to run a fleet if you haven’t had a position higher than XO. People should try running a ship first before they try running a fleet. How are they going to tell a CO how they should handle their ship if they haven’t tried it themselves?

I know I’m an oddball case as I was Vice President twice before I had a CO position, so I had a weird amount of experience for someone who hadn’t been a CO. I still think it was good that I tried being a CO before I was FComm.

Adam

I agree with Adam.

I still would also like the 6 month activity provision to be added as well. The only argument against that which I haven’t already replied to is “why would we do that if we are trying to expand the candidate pool?” My response to that is that we aren’t trying to expand the pool, we’re modernizing a rule. Further, nobody has actually gone to the effort of explaining why it would be necessary to expand the pool, other than to tell a story about a second assistant position that would be completely unaffected by this change. Someone should actually explain if and why they think the pool for FComm/AFComm is too small if that’s the actual reason this is being proposed.

Joe

I third Adam, and second Joe. Both of these provisions ensure a level of experience that is required to properly run a Fleet.

-Thomas

Use the full posts index to browse this ship's thread list.

Open Full Posts Index