Remove Tag?

Do you want to untag yourself from this post?

The Command Ship

Open Session- July 2023

Posted by Steve Johnson in Open Session- July 2023

Posted by Vice Admiral Robert Archer (Engineering DIrector) in Open Session- July 2023

Posted by Fleet Captain Sage Pennington (President) in Open Session- July 2023
Posted by… suppressed (5) by the Post Ghost! 👻
I would like to raise a question of my own this month, but other discussions remain both welcome and encouraged. How would you go about bringing in and retaining new players? Is there anything about that entry process for new players that you would change?

-Prez

So this is my opinion. Personally I feel we as a club need to fix our own internal problems first with what we got now before we can focus harder on new members. If we cant keep the members we got now how will new members stay if those same problems still exist?

This is my feelings, and from talking to various people new, and old or senior alike (new in my term being less then 1 year member, old being 1-2+, and senior being 5+ in this case). The general information I keep feeling myself and hearing from others many who say they don’t often speak up for fear of causing ‘drama’ or ‘make a big deal’ or ‘just feel it gets forgotten about’ say pretty much the same. Things are hard to find, things are out of date, things are said to ‘be in the works’ or ‘to be updated’ or similar and its been said like that for 1-2+ years. I think if we could find a reasonable way to quickly update library and other document changes as they happen within a month or so, and maybe revisit layout of the site to access said information and find a balance between a minimalist/well designed information layouts would help people getting frustrated at finding one thing or another.

I know a lot of this lays on members of TECH who volunteer their time to the club and this isnt a job for them. But if our structure of updating and maintenance of the site is said to need a database migra4tion and software update to XYZ and it goes 1+ years after first being mentioned publicly, same for a library update and such related to this, then how are we members who do other things supposed to do our own tasks? I appreciate this site and everyone past and present who’s done work on the backend. I wish I had more skills for that which I could help with, but TBH I can’t even remember the last time any constant active effort was pushed by TECH or anyone to really get the word out constantly on getting people to try to help and become engaged. It just feels like 2-3/4 people which only has 1 person who I ever see help or talk about anything. So I don’t know what else to say about this end of things for updating the site’s library and such. But it is definitely something which we as a club need to take a major look at....


I think something key to emphasize there is that TECH is a group of volunteers. You did mention it, but I’d like to emphasize it because the demand on their time to fix this, change that, add this… it’s not insignificant. I know TECH is working and working hard because at the start of this term we had a new email forward system and when a spam problem arose, they were on it. When the idea for the Zoo page was pitched, they laid the foundations for Louis to build on. The migration and library update are big projects. The work is being done, and we probably won’t see any of it until they’re done. At times it does create difficulties but we rely on TECH for a thousand little things that go less noticed but do take time away from the bigger projects. A little slack when things take time is not out of line.

So you are right on this, and as I said I do get that and mentioned it. But for the sake of site stability I think its only fair to ask if after over a year or more TECH mentioned the server move and library update and nothing has happened. At least being more communicative would not be out of line would it? Keep us all in the loop on what’s going challenges faced, basic reason for delays or continued delays. I totally can agree to giving slack but a little return communication once in a while would equally be nice so people keep informed and don’t start widely speculate and spread misinformation/incorrect information/rumors etc or give the impression to some that things are said to happen but actually nothing is being done.

Like you say below about Katy’s fix suggestion, I think a little communication from TECH would also be an easy fix to at least keeping us non-tech people informed.

The next thing I would say before we look at a large ‘new member’ push to help fix what we already have is look hard at ship health and fleet health. I know this is a sticky issue for some, but I feel part of the ‘poor image’ of ships is also to a point not quite as bad as it could be if we look at what defines a ‘healthy’ ship vs what seems to be the ‘cultural expectations of a healthy ship’ currently.

So what do I mean by this second part? In short FCOMM defines a healthy ship:

They must maintain an enjoyable environment that is beneficial for both the ship and the club as a whole.
They must maintain a crew of reliable players, with the majority within the ship-specific AWOL guidelines.
They must manage to function as a Standard Ship successfully, with due regard to the current time period and technology level.

These above 1st and 2nd and the 4th ones here are pretty obvious to most, but I find often when I am talking to current CO’s or something the next one often stumps or surprises a lot because they hear or are taught otherwise.

They must maintain, within reason, a full command and senior staff, defined as a Commanding Officer, an Executive Officer, a Gamemaster, a Chief Engineer, a Chief Medical Officer, a Chief Science Officer, and a Chief of Security. Any command-level vacancy must be filled within 14 days of its occurrence.

Now ignoring for a moment that last sentence of filling a command vacancy in 14 days, the part before in short means JOs are NOT a needed thing on any ship. They are enjoyed and ideal sure. But they are NOT a mandatory thing. In short a ship COULD get away with 6 players! In fact also not needed technically on ships is that of a CNS (baring the academy I believe?) and while CNS’s are traditionally set as a DH nothing as far as I have ever read in STF rules says they could not be marked at a posting rate of a jo (again barring academy I think?), so for example say on my ship the Ark Angel, my CNS which I normally have as a DH posting every 5 days, needs just a little more breathing time to post I have no problem putting them to 7 days like the jo’s it has often lead to me able to continue with a current CNS player who just had a bit of a sudden rush come up in life that they normally would go awol or drop the ship. So even if we were to consider a CNS as a mandatory role on a ship that still only brings a required player count up to 7.

So what I’m saying I guess is if we push the above idea to current ships we also then look at our current JO’s and see who can fill open DH roles. I also find that often it is voiced its the same older people in the same roles, JO’s having little chance to move up to DH spots which are often quickly filled with old hats. I’ve seen and heard CO’s and such on ships filling a DH spot with a older member they are familiar with. Again I know CO’s are given freedom to fill their vacancies as they wish, I agree with this to a point. But if we are alienating our younger members time and again they’ll only get frustrated and leave for better opportunities elsewhere. I also think the various FComms/AFComms and GM Dept and CO/XO teams in my opinion should where possible be more engaging in looking at ships and when they see a talented player who lets say could do well as a future GM they get an email or something for it. Same for CO/XO roles for JOs or DHs not having been doing these before. I recall in the past it was only by a few folks encouraging me to apply to be a DH, then XO/CO then GM that I ever considered the roles. Partly because I was not sure I could do it or it seemed confusing or something else. If we folks who are at the higher levels of experience in the club taking a guiding lead in those younger then us we can keep and gain the next generation of members to feel engaged in our community as a whole.

As for new members? TBH until we can make major inroads into dealing with our current internal problems I dont to me feel like investsing huge amounts of time getting new blood only to loose it.

Just my thoughts....

Robert Archer EDir

I need some further time to digest everything Rob said above, but I do second his opinion that we need to look internally before we start trying to “fix the new player problem.”

As one of the people here who regularly interacts with our newest members, the quick exit of a lot of applications is not something we can just snap our fingers and fix. Many people are applying because they want to try out our system/style, and once they decide they don’t like it, they bounce. There is not much we can do about that, no matter how many e-mails we send.

If you look back, the % of people who pop in, take a look, and then bail, remains pretty consistent. What has been changing is the number of applications that come in. For example, we have a 20% retention rate, and we get 15 applications that month, I’d expect for there to be 3 people who make it past 30 days. But if we only get 4 applications in a month, we’d be lucky to keep 1 past 30 days.

Without a giant influx of new members, the only way we are going to slow, or stop, the shrinking of our group is to look at our current group of members, and ask what we can do to keep them from also leaving.

Steve

I can agree with the above, I mean the CNS position on the Wolverine has had a posting speed of 7 days since I became CO. Furthermore, STF’s infrastructure is too large for the number of active members. Four Fleets, around 19 rp environments, and an academy ship (that doesn’t even have a Cadet) seem excessive for a membership of around 60-70 people. Cutting another fleet (and ships), could potentially cut the number of vacancies or positions needed to be filled. If my character was a DH on a cut ship, I’d gladly move them over to another as a JO. Downsizing also fixes our GM shortage :)

If we don’t start correcting the issues we’re facing, STF is going to disappear. It’s not a matter of it, but when.

-Ray

On a semi-related note, can I make a request? All major documents from the Library that have been updated get placed in one central location? It doesn’t do much for member retention if someone’s told “XYZ is in FCOMM” but it’s not in FCOMM in the library, it’s in the updated FCOMM that’s somewhere in the listing of old edicts that I’m sure most members don’t even know exists.

It doesn’t need to be permanently on the front page, but a few links on the Command MOTD would be helpful, if nothing else, then so that someone referring someone to the document can say “It’s in FCOMM, the one in the library’s outdated, here’s the new one”. I don’t remember for sure which documents have been updated, but I know FCOMM was at least once wince the move to Exodus.

Katy

So. There’s been a great deal of this “merge fleets and cut ships” talk for the last several terms. I took the liberty of doing a little research on the last few terms. Here’s a list of the ships we’ve cut in the last couple years:
September 8, 2021 - USS Dresden
March 24, 2022 - USS Constellation
April 28, 2022 - Outpost 42
April 29, 2022 - USS Viking
August 14, 2022 - USS Odin
July 19, 2023 - USS Europa

I am not about to say those cuts were unjustified. That said, if you look at the club in 2021 compared to now, are we any better off? Is there a saturation point of cuts that we do suddenly benefit? At what point do we see returns? That’s six ships since September 2021. Six crews disbanded and some players lost in the process. Rob pointed out something which I had been discussing with someone else only a few days ago. Ships could be crewed by fewer people, being mainly DHs. We could emphasize upward mobility and taking a chance on a new person, and being open to the new person who asks for a chance. I got my first DH role because I went looking for vacancies. I found one and a CO took a chance on a relatively new player. Now here we are. Upward mobility. Ultimately, cutting another ship reduces the number of roles for which people can apply, and for what return? We are not a large club. But large enough that we could have 9 or 10 ships fully crewed without anyone having a second character. I think a great deal of people came here with the goal and ambition of becoming a CO, sitting in the center chair. To advance and write as one of the “main cast”. JOs not being strictly speaking necessary, we could fill the existing DH vacancies without net increasing the number of active characters. And it may be time to do so.

To Katy’s point, perhaps an updated version of Dan’s guide to making a post in Command is in order. The post itself is valuable but the links to major bylaws may be outdated. This seems like a solvable problem.

-President Sage Pennington

Robert Archer

Unfortunately the major bylaws are out of date as well because of previous limitations of the old Library system. This is something that we were aiming to address in the new Library, once it was able to be implemented.

But to your point, it is often that people get “stuck” in their positions here in STF, and don’t have a chance for upward movement. For example, the CO opening for Olinski was never posted anywhere. Kieron is a first time CO, and I wish him the best of luck. But what if I had been named CO? Once again someone new would have been cut out of having the chance to move up. And as few CO openings as we tend to have each year, how many times has a “returning experienced member” been giving the CO spot?

We often have CO’s who remain in their positions for years on end. Sometimes doing a great job, and sometimes not. Perhaps a solution is more change in the CO position on ships. For example, a max cap of 5 years in the position of CO, before a mandatory 1 year hiatus before you could be a CO again. This would give more people an opportunity to step up to the center seat, and give more experience players an opportunity to step back and relax every now and then.

As another option, perhaps we should look at bringing back our in sim CO Training curriculum to the Challenger. Back in the day, the CO position was only an IC position. The true commanding officer of the Challenger held the XO position, and acted as a mentor to the CO. The idea was to give them some time getting used to being in command, give them more prep in how the backend of running a ship happens, etc.

With the limited number of new members we are currently getting right now, it would give the Challenger crew something else to do while we wait for new members to join.

Steve

I think the biggest part of the problem, as I have briefly mentioned (ages ago, admittedly) in previous posts, is the fact that experience seems to be valued over all else anymore. I obviously can’t go back to see, but I vaguely remember quite a few XO postings requesting experience. And a lot of COs go with experienced players for DHs instead of offering it to the JOs of that department, then to the JOs of the rest of the departments, first. At least, it appears that way to an outside observer.

Foremost Fleet has 6 ships in it. Of those, very few are “unique” or new players. It’s all the same old suspects.

I am on the fence about limiting a CO’s time. What do we do for some ships that would require a drastic restructuring without the current CO? The Ark Angel would require TWO positions to be filled (CO and GM) and the Merrimack has had the same CO for how long now? Yes, it’s a problem for COs staying in their positions for a long time, but I have an even better idea:

For one, actually hold past actions on that ship against a CO. I’m not going to name anyone, but I know of several COs in the club that I have told people about their problems repeatedly (as have other people) and nothing is done about them. Nothing is done about COs who are unexcused with reports for months on end, nothing is done about COs who routinely have extreme AWOLs on their board, nothing is done about COs who don’t properly enforce AWOL limits.

I won’t say anyone is perfect, but long term actions need to lead to some sort of consequence, then we’d have openings for people to move into!

Katy

Use the full posts index to browse this ship's thread list.

Open Full Posts Index