The Command Ship
Office of the President - Edict #5
Posted by Ben Z in Office of the President - Edict #5
Posted by Vice Admiral Thomas (Mentors Coordinator) in Office of the President - Edict #5
Posted by Ben Z in Office of the President - Edict #5
Posted by… suppressed (1) by the Post Ghost! 👻
<SNIP>
Hi Sarah,My initial post on the subject touches on many of the topics you’ve mentioned here, so if you would like to review it, it is at the top of this thread. I have clearly laid out why the opinions of ‘Person A’ matter. But, if a discussion really would be an empty gesture, a ‘pretense’ with no actual intent by you to learn and grow from a potentially constructive and enlightening discussion… then you are right, and we should all be prepared to let you do as you please point-blank-period. You have made as much clear, and I am in turn making it clear that I strongly disapprove of that method of governance.
I don’t believe that more than a ‘subset of the club’ will EVER post on Command if they have been given the clear message that their posts do not matter. You have made it very clear that ‘Person A’ does not matter to you, and there are many, many ‘Person A’s in this club. I caution against labeling anyone not directly affected by a decision as unimportant, both for the reasons I mentioned above, and for the additional reason that ‘Person B’ will then always be alone if this is the case, unable to ask for support from other members of the club whose opinion you shun (especially, it seems, if those opinions disagree with yours).
If these decisions truly are as difficult as you claim, they deserve the time and attention of all members of the club, not just you and a select few. This idea that you are saving the club by making unpopular decisions that other people are simply too stupid to understand are needed is frankly insulting. You have made these decisions not difficult… precisely because you have avoided the hardest part: managing the reaction from club members. People want to believe that you have good intentions, but having faith in your administration should not be the same as agreeing to blind obedience.
I often wonder how newer members view posts like yours above. It certainly seems to imply that you have a negative opinion of most everyone in the club, especially those that do not agree with you. I suggest that you consider the perception the less outspoken members have of your actions. Whatever your intentions, the way you go about them does matter. You have discarded my constructive criticism in that regard, and for that I am disappointed. But at least we should now all be on the same page about what to expect going forward. So thank you for answering my question.
Ben
Hi Ben,
I haven’t shared any thoughts on this discussion, but I am going to offer some briefly as the only other President in recent club history who has decommissioned a fleet (two, if memory serves).
Several years ago, during a time of acute GM shortage and when we had a myriad of problems, it was necessary to decommission several ships. This was a very long process done in collaboration with COs, FComms, myself, and the Veep at the time, and the perspective of those with significant experience otherwise was also sought. Along with the ship cuts, two fleets were decommissioned and merged into one, new, fleet - the Infinite Fleet.
One thing that didn’t happen, that I recall (though this is almost 10 years ago now), is an extended public discussion. Why was this? We had the input needed from the people involved. It did no one any good to complicate things by bringing in the opinion of people unaffected by the changes. It isn’t that those opinions did not matter, it’s that they had no benefit or loss from the changes. I think you have read in a lot of content into Sarah’s phrasing that does not exist. The reality here is that there are people that are considered above others with considerations like this. That’s not wrong, it’s just.
Here is an unfortunate but blunt truth: it is easier for people to be outraged by a change than it is for people to put energy into preventing a change. I went into the ship cut process years ago with the certainty that, as objectively needed as it was, there would be people angered by it. There would be people hurt by it. Those facts did not make those actions unneccessary. Sometimes what is necessary is not what is popular. It being unpopular does not make it wrong. People insisting that the popular thing is right, on the other hand, are often responding to emotion, not fact.
Aside from those things, this discussion is surprising to me. I feel like there is more negative outcry to this than there were to the ship cuts I performed, which is perplexing. The Infinite Fleet was fairly young. It had little to no existing fleet culture - contrary to what some have said. Most of all, there are no changes of any note to the actual ships. The people upset, it seems, are mostly people who are not direclty affected by this. This makes me wonder - what cause are these folks acting to? Like I said earlier, it is easier to be outraged by change than it is to put work into making something thrive. That’s one of many things this club has taught me over my years here.
Unpopular though it may be, none of the actions taken here are improper or out of step with historical precedent. The amount of energy applied to these discussions, had it been directed elsewhere, could have been put to a productive use. This is not a good use of time. There has been a segment of the club’s population - generally older members (of which I am now one) - who discuss the way it “used to be” the whole time I have been here. If all the negative or lamentous words typed in such posts were put into positive interest in the club, writing, and a goodwill engagement into OOC efforts, I think there would be less for those folks to lament. The reality is it does no good to lament those things - whether they ever truly were or not. All it does is make the writer feel bad, make some readers feel bad, make some readers angry, and does no good for the club.
Anyway. I am surprised at the amount of energy directed to these threads. It’s unfortunate.
-Thomas
Hi Thomas,
If you have read my posts on this subject, you will notice I refrain from passing judgement on whether the action in of itself is right or wrong. And, I have clearly explained why there is a real loss from the way these changes were implemented for me: a loss of confidence in the administration and their willingness to have basic respect for other members of the club. I am not asking that everyone be given equal weight in this decision. Only that people not directly impacted be given any weight at all.
I also never said that the popular thing is right. In fact, it seems to me that those in favor of this change are currently posting more on Command. What I did say, is that framing this as a ‘difficult’ decision made for the benefit of a few despite the angry mob of the masses is just a way of discrediting the opinions of other members of the club. And those opinions matter because they are members of the club. The COs of the ships affected have brought up a repeatedly. There are a lot more characters and writers on ships than just the COs. I wonder if those less influential members were consulted at all. Or if the response will be ‘they didn’t matter because we don’t NEED to consult them to do this’.
As for what ‘cause’ I am ‘acting to,’ I invite you to read the poem “First They Came…” by Martin Niemoller. I care about things that happen to other people because they could also happen to me. If you allow other people to be treated badly, eventually you will be treated the same way.
I’m sorry that you feel as if this discussion isn’t important. I would encourage you to find a productive way to spend your time in the future. However, please refrain from telling other people what they should or should not value. I find it very important, and never a waste of time, to voice my concerns about issues I have about how an organization I am a part of is treating me and others. I hope that you also find value in speaking up for yourself and those you care about in the future when you determine that it is necessary to do so. And when you decide to, I hope no on tells you that it is ‘unfortunate’ that you did.
Ben
“First they came…” was written on reflection of the Nazis gassing and murdering millions of people. To use that example and compare the deletion of a menu item on an internet game is farcical. No ships were cut, no characters removed, no decades-long culture destroyed. This wasn’t a fleet that has been here since the start with annals of history. I commissioned it, 6 years ago. To portray this as harm is obtuse, and makes actual decisions of controversy the lesser for it. Consulting with every single person in the club about a decision is not the way this club is or has ever been run. Additionally, it is simply not possible, or even a good idea. I do social work, and advocate professionally every day for people who don’t have homes, jobs, or opportunity. I know what value there is in speaking up. The same experience instructs on the importance of picking battles. No one was treated badly here, and if people think they were, they simply have no idea what being treated badly in this club looks like. That’s simply the truth.
-Thomas
I made no such comparison. You asked me to justify why I would get involved in a decision that did not directly impact me, and I shared a core piece of my moral compass, as represented by that poem. I apply the wisdom in those words to a variety of contexts, and if you are implying that we should not use the lessons learned from that horrible event to inform our everyday lives, I suggest that you reflect on that.
Fortunately, you and I are different people, and can decide for ourselves which battles are worth fighting. Trying to convince me that this one is not simply because YOU do not find it valuable will not be a successful strategy.
The only reason this discussion has become so philosophical and divorced from my actual concern is that it has been repeatedly demanded of me that I have some profound reason for a simple request: involve the club more in relatively big decisions like this, if you want to make them. That is not an unreasonable request, nor should it be necessary for me to resort to having to defend my right to even “fight the battle” as you put it. If you disagree with that request on principle, that is your right. But to try and dictate to me what I should or should not do with my time and energy is out of line.
Ben
Amazing.
-Thomas