The Command Ship
Proposal: FCOMM change
Posted by Sharon Miller in Proposal: FCOMM change
Posted by Vice Admiral Thomas (Mentors Coordinator) in Proposal: FCOMM change
Posted by Captain Katy Darrah (AFComm, Meridian Fleet) in Proposal: FCOMM change
Currently, Standard Ships, as defined by FCOMM are as follows:A Standard Ship is any self-contained RPG Starship or Starbase, commanded by a CO, on which regular RPGs take place under the administration of the GameMaster Department and the Fleet Commander. All Standard Ships must reside in a Fleet and be a Starfleet vessel or starbase. Additionally, all Standard Ships are set approximately 376 years after the current modern year. That is, the year 2000 real time corresponds to the year 2376 In Character time, and one-year real time corresponds to approximately one year RPG time.
Also, as stated here: https://www.star-fleet.com/core/command/command/posts/100867/ by Sarah, FCOMM defines a standard ship as “nothing special” theme wise.
However, because we do have so many ships we now consider standard, I’d like to propose an amendment to FCOMM, to read as follows. I have bolded my additions
A Standard Ship is any self-contained RPG Starship or Starbase, commanded by a CO, on which regular RPGs take place under the administration of the GameMaster Department and the Fleet Commander. All Standard Ships must reside in a Fleet and be a Starfleet vessel or starbase. A Standard Ship may also be a ship which adds additional, fitting, themes to a ship, such as Marines, or carrying fighters. Theme appropriateness is to be determined by the Executive, however, it should not detract from the ship being otherwise a Standard Ship. In addition, these themes should not require a GM specialized in Alternative RPG environments. Additionally, all Standard Ships are set approximately 376 years after the current modern year. That is, the year 2000 real time corresponds to the year 2376 In Character time, and one-year real time corresponds to approximately one year RPG time.
Changes: Added how a reasonably themed ship–like that of a carrier–could be considered Standard
Katy
I am supportive of this change, however, I don’t think the Executive needs to be involved. A thematic decision should be something between the CO and the ship and then the FComm for approval. I think if it is so dramatic as to need Executive approval that is when an alt-RPG may be more appropriate. As someone said elsewhere (Sharon? Can’t remember) - themes can come and go. (Anticipating a question: how do we define dramatic? I would define it as something that is either a) more permanent and will require attention from the GM to specialize sims; and/or b) a theme so contrary to the expected behavior of a ship that it would require significant prep for a player to get into, not unlike other alt-rps here.)
Thanks,
-ThomasOkay, so before I state my opinion on this, I’d just like to clarify something. Katy says above:
Also, as stated here: https://www.star-fleet.com/core/command/command/posts/100867/ by Sarah, FCOMM defines a standard ship as “nothing special” theme wise.
The term used wasn’t “nothing special” but “nothing unique”, which I feel is distinctly different. In fact, Sarah’s full sentence, in the linked post, was “I’ve chatted a bit with Larry, who wrote the original FCOMM version, and his indication to me was that Standard Ship should essentially be substitutable for one another in that there is nothing unique about them.”
So onto my opinion. If the yardstick by which we are measuring is that one standard ship can be substituted for another, then I completely disagree that ships with marine battalions or fighter wings attached to them can be swapped out for ships that don’t have these features, or even for each other. In fact, I’d go so far as to say that I’d find it easier, thematically, to substitute a ship that’s uniqueness is ‘comedy’ than one whose uniqueness is ‘a marine battalion’. Now, of course, I’m sure others would disagree with me entirely there, but then that’s really my main point, that all of this is starting to feel incredibly subjective on what we are or are not willing to consider an ‘alt-RP’, and due to that, which ships should or should not have to jump through the additional hoops of an alt-charter to exist.
Now, don’t get me wrong, I’m not necessarily opposing an amendment to FComm outright. In fact I’m all in favour of loosening the rules around what we consider ‘a ship that doesn’t need an alt-charter’. But I personally feel like this is being approached from the wrong angle when a ship with a horror or comedic atmosphere is considered to be ‘non-standard’ and yet a ship with a marine battalion isn’t.
- Sharon
Thing is, yes, it requires some non-trek acceptance, but I can see a ship with marines being FAR more “normal” than a comedy ship.
Marines also don’t require super special sims. You can work them in like any other department. It’s more of like a swing department rather than a “theme” per se, I mean the entire ship isn’t marines, is it?
You try working Marines into a sim. It’s fairly simple, from a sim-runner’s point of view. I can treat them like any other department. Run drills if I don’t have anything specialized, or I can have a sim where there’s an away mission, or a need for a team to transport over to a ship to provide combat support (like having to try and stop a ship from being boarded by the Borg). Or even to prevent your ship from being boarded!
There’s 5 ideas to work the marines in–that could work on LITERALLY any ship. But try doing that with a comedy ship. It’s hard to work the theme of the Connie into an existing sim. Take my sim on the AA, the comedy theme would be almost entirely ignored in the main sim, and with the exception of side sims–and maybe even a side plot entirely–may not even be present!
It’s much harder to work in a theme like what’s on the Connie vs the theme of Marines. The two are NOT substitutable. You need to develop a sim with the Connie in mind. ANY sim can work for a Marine theme with only a few tweaks.
So before we talk whether a theme is considered normal, let’s look at whether two ships could ACTUALLY substitute for each other–hint, in this case, they can’t.
Katy